Uncategorized

The Price Of ERISA Preemption: The Regulator Congress Never Funded

In this October 1 Health Affairs Forefront article, Scott Levy argues that Congress shields self-insured employer health plans from state insurance regulation without adequately funding the federal oversight intended to protect workers.

His main points:

  • Employer oversight is weak. Many employers lack the expertise, information and bargaining power to monitor their third-party administrators (TPAs) and pharmacy benefit managers (PBMs). About one-third did not compare competing vendor offers.
  • Federal oversight is understaffed. The Labor Department’s Employee Benefits Security Administration (EBSA) oversees health plans covering 156 million people, plus retirement plans. Its funded staffing fell from 840 in 2006 to 687 in fiscal 2026, despite expanding responsibilities.
  • A small assessment could fund stronger enforcement. Charging self-insured plans $1 per covered person annually would generate approximately $100 million, nearly half EBSA’s fiscal 2025 budget.
  • Vendors need direct accountability. Levy proposes explicitly making TPAs and PBMs ERISA fiduciaries, allowing enforcement against their conduct across multiple plans.

Relevance to state work: Levy proposes strengthening federal oversight while retaining ERISA preemption. His proposal would not give states authority to require self-insured employers to participate

READ MORE

Leave a Reply